Tuesday, December 30, 2025

New Deal Accomplishment: 7,000 historic American buildings surveyed by 1941; 34,000 by 2025


Above: Workers measuring the columns at the Kentucky School for the Blind, Louisville, Kentucky, March 16, 1934. This project was part of the new Historic American Buildings Survey (HABS), carried out by the New Deal's Civil Works Administration (CWA), in conjunction with the National Park Service. Unemployed architects and draftsmen were hired to do the job. Photo by Theodore Webb, courtesy of the Library of Congress.


Above: Drawings and measurements of the columns, part of the finished survey of the School for the Blind (see previous photo). Image from the Library of Congress.


Above: These CWA workers are restoring the Dey Mansion to its original appearance, New Jersey, 1934. The Dey Mansion was one of several buildings that George Washington used as headquarters during the American Revolution. An extensive 2-page article about the highly-skilled CWA restoration work appeared in the February 22, 1934 edition of the Paterson Evening News (Paterson, New Jersey). After the mansion was restored, and after the CWA ended, it was added to HABS by the CWA's successor agency, the Work division of the Federal Emergency Relief Administration (FERA). The HABS materials can be found on the website of the Library of Congress, here. Photo from: Henry G. Alsberg, America Fights the Depression: A Photographic Record of the Civil Works Administration, New York: Coward-McCann Publishers, 1934, used here for educational and non-commercial purposes.


Above: After CWA and FERA ended, the WPA continued adding buildings to the HABS inventory, 1935-1941. Photo from the National Archives.


Above: Another church that the WPA added to HABS. Photo from the National Archives.


Above: A WPA-HABS drawing of Chatham Windmill, Chatham, Massachusetts. "Washington, D.C." is on this photo card because completed surveys were sent to the Library of Congress for preservation. You can actually see this drawing on the Library of Congress's website, here. Photo from the National Archives.

Above: After the New Deal, "the [HABS] program transitioned into summer work projects for students overseen by qualified architects and related professionals" (Virginia Murison, AIA, Consulting Preservation Architect, "About the Historic American Buildings Survey (HABS)," Historic Hawaii Foundation, June 18, 2025). The HABS work for the "Sofio Fernandez House," in Llano Quemado, New Mexico, was performed in part by two students from the University of New Mexico, 1963-1964. Image from the Library of Congress.


Above: One of several HABS drawings for Eagle Creek Overlook Shelter, Oregon. This shelter was built by the Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC) and overlooks the Columbia River and Bonneville Dam. The survey was performed by students from the University of Oregon, with Professor of Architecture Donald Peting supervising, 1994. Image from the Library of Congress.


Above: Part of the floor plan for "Stulting Place," the birthplace of Pearl Buck, in Hillsboro, West Virginia. This HABS survey was completed by Grigg, Wood, Browne & Williams Architects in 1972. Image from the Library of Congress.


Above: The New Deal not only created HABS, to help preserve Pearl Buck's birthplace--as well as tens of thousands of other structures--but also created West Virginia's historic roadside marker program. Through its legislation, HABS, roadside markers, physical restoration work, record-finding & inventorying, Index of American Design, archaeology & museum projects, publications on state & local histories (the Federal Writers' Project), and more, the New Deal became a historic preservation juggernaut. Photos by Brent McKee, 2015.


Above: Though less-focused (but not entirely unfocused) on the precise and technical aspects of architecture, such as measurements, and more focused on history and place, the Living New Deal, like HABS, preserves the memory of buildings should they be lost - by mapping, historical research, and photography, either by our team members, national associates, or other interested individuals. Seen above is the former WPA-built gym in Manteo, North Carolina. This interesting and steadfast structure, monolithic in appearance and with utterly gorgeous carpentry work in the ceiling area, was demolished in 2013, not long after this photo was taken. For more information and photos (including the carpentry work), see the Living New Deal webpage, "Manteo School Gym (Demolished) - Manteo NC." Photo by a Manteo resident, 2013.


Above: No doubt inspired by the success of HABS, the Historic American Merchant Marine Survey (HAMMS) was carried out by the WPA, and sponsored by the Smithsonian Institution, 1936-1937. "This project is designed to give work to unemployed naval architects, designers, and draftsmen" ("Two Polar Ship Pictures Given To U.S. Museum: Smithsonian Gets Exact Drawing of Base Ships of Peary and Amundsen," Journal-Every Evening (Wilmington, Delaware), April 15, 1937, p. 10). Above, we see work being performed on the LaForrest L. Simmons schooner, Baltimore, Maryland, for HAMMS. This photo is dated February 1939, perhaps indicating that the ship had already been added to HAMMS or that supplemental information was being collected. Photo from the National Archives.

34,000+ Buildings Surveyed

By 1941, the New Deal--through its various work-relief programs--had inventoried 7,000 structures for the HABS project. By 2025, that figure was over 34,000. Further, HABS inspired similar projects, such as the Historic American Engineering Record (HAER) and the Historical American Landscapes Survey (HALS).

During the initial years of HABS, it was the formerly-unemployed--working in CWA, FERA, and WPA that did the leg work, the grunt work, and the architectural drawings, measurements, and photographs. It was the formerly-unemployed, who had been ridiculed and belittled (as always seems to happen during business-cycle downturns) who developed one of America's greatest historic preservation programs. This fact is often glossed-over or even entirely forgotten today. It shouldn't be. 

Monday, December 22, 2025

New Deal Accomplishment: 8,000,000 Christmas toys for children in need


Above: A WPA worker in New Orleans making doll furniture for Christmas distribution, between 1935 and 1942. Photo from the National Archives.


Above: WPA workers at "Fire Station No. 15," repairing toys for Christmas distribution, St. Paul, Minnesota, between 1935 and 1943. Photo from the National Archives.


Above: An unemployed carpenter, now working in the WPA, repairs toys at Fire Station No. 15 (see previous photo). The WPA did its best to match the skills of the unemployed to available relief jobs - and what better match than a carpenter making wooden toys for children in need during the holidays? Photo from the National Archives.


Above: Two WPA workers at Fire Station No. 15 (see previous two photos) repaint used toys - a race car and steam shovel. Photo from the National Archives.


Above: WPA worker Roy Bridgeman, refurbishing a toy at the Peabody School, Minneapolis, Minnesota, between 1935 and 1942, "for distribution to needy children at Christmas time by the Child Welfare Department of the Board of Education." Quote and photo from the National Archives.


Above: At this WPA toy shop in New York City, workers are putting surplus cotton in stuffed toys, "for distribution to needy children at Christmas time," between 1935 and 1942. Quote and photo from the National Archives.


Above: In addition to Christmas toys, the WPA operated toy lending centers throughout the entire year, and in many cities and towns across nation, for children who didn't have as many play opportunities as other children. The lending center above is in Chicago, 1935-1943. Photo from the National Archives.


Above: The New Deal's National Youth Administration (NYA) also operated toy lending projects, such as this toy library in Westfield, New Jersey, 1935-1943. Photo from the National Archives.


Above: This is from the NYA's final report, p. 173, and gives us a general idea of the scope and operation of its toy projects.


Above: This photo, taken in New Orleans, ca. 1939, shows children from lower-income families looking over donated toys at a WPA toy lending center. The toys could be checked out, just like library books, and then returned. "At Christmas, however, the center plays the role of Santa Claus, taking gifts to many boys and girls to whom otherwise Christmas would be just another day." Quote and photo from the National Archives.


Above: In addition to distributing repaired toys and lending donated toys, the WPA produced its own toys, as seen in this toy-making project in Houston, Texas, 1939. Activities such as this were not seen as overly infringing on the private sector because the clients of such services were not participating in the private market in a significant way (to put it simply, they couldn't afford to). Photo from the National Archives.


Above: WPA sewing room workers contributed significantly to the production and repair of toys, both at Christmas and throughout the year. These workers are at a WPA toy-mending shop, 475 Tenth Avenue, New York City, between 1935 and 1943. Photo from the National Archives.


Above: Another scene at the WPA toy-mending shop in New York City (see previous photo). WPA toy projects offered employment to many, especially as Christmas approached, with as many as 50,000 WPA workers producing, collecting, repairing, and distributing toys ("1,500,000 Toys Rise From Trashpile To Make Needy Happy At Xmas Times," The Chicago Defender (Chicago, Illinois), December 24, 1938, p. 7). Photo from the National Archives.


Above: This is part of a much longer newspaper article, in the Trenton Sunday Times-Advertiser (Trenton, New Jersey), December 20, 1936, telling the incredible story of 13-year-old Richard Dawson, of Hightstown, New Jersey, and his friends, who learned woodworking skills in a WPA course; then created the "Richard Dawson Christmas Club"; and then solicited the help of the WPA to start a project to collect and repair toys for distribution to the less fortunate - "[Dawson] knew some boys and girls who never seemed to have very many playthings." The older man you see--in the photo at bottom right--is John Dieffenbach, a WPA carpenter assigned to supervise the program. Dear Hollywood: This would make a great Christmas movie! Image from newspapers.com, used here for educational and non-commercial purposes.

New Deal Santa

Cumulative statistics for New Deal toy projects were not well-calculated and/or well-reported in government reports. So, with respect to the production, repair, and distribution of toys for Christmas, the main subject of this blog post, we can try to piece together what happened (i.e., volume) by way of old newspaper accounts. Though the New Deal's toy projects seem to have started in earnest under the Work Division of the Federal Emergency Relief Administration (FERA)--and we're also carried out by the National Youth Administration (NYA)--nationwide totals could only be found for WPA:  

1935: About 1 million toys distributed by WPA workshops ("Work-Relief Wages Bring Millions Joy," United Press article, in the Indianapolis Times (Indianapolis, Indiana), December 25, 1935, p. 1).

1936: 725,000 ("Moments in Washington," The Indianapolis News (Indianapolis, Indiana), December 25, 1936, p. 7). 

1937: 1,500,000 ("WPA Toys: 1,500,000 Presents Ready for Yule," Washington Herald-Times (Washington, DC), December 19, 1937, p. 8).

1938: 1,500,000 ("1,500,000 Toys Rise From Trashpile To Make Needy Happy At Xmas Time," The Chicago Defender (Chicago, Illinois), December 24, 1938, p. 7).

1939: 1,500,000 ("WPA Workers Make Holiday Toys," Associated Press article, in Council Bluffs Nonpareil (Council Bluffs, Iowa), December 12, 1939, p. 13)

1940: 2,000,000 ("2,000,000 WPA Toys," Associated Press article, in the St. Louis Post-Dispatch (St. Louis, Missouri), December 15, 1940, p. 17C).

1941 and 1942: Nationwide statistics could not be found. Newspaper articles indicate that production dropped off significantly for these two Christmas seasons, mainly because defense-related and private sector employment began reducing the number of workers on the WPA payroll, as well as the number of families in need of assistance. The articles suggest that WPA toy production, repair, and distribution were still noteworthy in 1941, but probably running on fumes during the holiday season of 1942. For example, there is a 1941 Associated Press article reporting that 160,000 WPA toys would be distributed in New Jersey (The Jersey Journal (Jersey City, New Jersey), December 17, 1941); a 1941 article noting that 14 WPA toy centers were operating in Montana ("State Toy Projects Have Finished Big Job," Fergus County Argus (Lewistown, Montana), December 25, 1941, p. 5); and a story in 1942--among much fewer newspaper articles on the subject--reported that children in Hartford, Connecticut would be receiving 7,000 WPA toys for Christmas ("City Has 7,000 WPA Toys For Yule Distribution," The Hartford Courant, December 17, 1942, p. 4).

Using just the WPA statistics from 1935 through 1940, we see that the New Deal produced, repaired, and distributed over 8 million Christmas toys to underprivileged children. The totals from FERA, NYA, and the last two years of WPA would likely raise this total to well over 10 million.

Monday, December 15, 2025

New Deal Accomplishment: Over two million African Americans hired


Above: Payday on a Civil Works Administration (CWA) project. It's not clear how many African Americans received jobs through the CWA or its successor agency, the Work Division of the Federal Emergency Relief Administration (FERA). In some cases it seems that the numbers hired, and the wages paid, were enough to cause farmers and business owners to complain that they no longer had enough low-wage workers to hire (see, e.g., Forrest A. Walker, The Civil Works Administration: An Experiment in Federal Work Relief, 1933-1934, 1979, pp. 69-70). However, overall CWA and FERA employment of African Americans was probably not adequate or equitable. Photo from: Henry G. Alsberg, America Fights the Depression: A Photographic Record of the Civil Works Administration, New York: Coward-McCann Publishers, 1934, used here for educational and non-commercial purposes.


Above: Members of Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC) Company 352, stationed at Camp NHP-1, Yorktown, Virginia, ca. 1937. These men--and several other African American CCC companies--helped restore and preserve Colonial National Historical Park, a park that now sees millions of visitors annually, supports thousands of jobs, and contributes nearly half-a-billion dollars to the local economy every year (see, "Tourism to Colonial National Historical Park creates over $453 million in Economic Benefits," National Park Service, July 17, 2022). Over 250,000 African Americans served in the CCC (see, e.g., Federal Security Agency, "The Civilian Conservation Corps and Colored Youth," May 1940, accessed December 13, 2025). CCC enrollment of African Americans typically reflected the percentage of the U.S. population that was African American (about 10%) but in some cases exceeded it (see, e.g., "CCC Enrollment Data Discussed Here," Monmouth Democrat (Freehold, New Jersey), February 23, 1939, p. 1, reporting 22.7% African American CCC enrollment in a county with 9.4% African American population. Photo above from: Civilian Conservation Corps, District No. 4, Third Corps Area, 1933-1937 (Harrisburg, PA: The Military Service Publishing Co., 1937), used here for educational and non-commercial purposes.


Above: There's no shortage of modern articles and analyses criticizing, if not excoriating the CCC's treatment of African American enrollees. These critiques usually zero-in on the negatives, spend too-little time explaining the positives, and make too much use of anecdotal evidence (see, e.g., Amy McCullough, "Rethinking the CCC, Black Labor, and the History of Our Parks," The Trust for Public Land, February 2, 2025). But African Americans who lived through those times appreciated the job and training opportunities that the CCC (and the NYA, see below) offered. To fully understand the CCC, we must step out of our modern shoes and step into the shoes of the past. The article above is from The Pittsburgh Courier, April 4, 1942. Image from newspapers.com, used here for educational and non-commercial purposes.


Above: The description for this photograph--taken around 1940--reads: "Antionette Lee reading to the children at 28th St. School, Los Angeles, Calif., day nursery for caring for younger brothers and sisters of students of district schools, as part of her duties under the National Youth Administration Student Work Program." In fiscal year 1940, the NYA employed 64,000 African Americans through its in-school program, out of a total of 748,000 - about 8.5%. Photo from the National Archives.


Above: Two NYA men working in a machine shop, ca. 1940. In fiscal year 1940, the NYA employed 72,000 African Americans in its out-of-school work program, out of a total of 575,000 - about 12.5%. Photo from: Federal Security Agency, National Youth Administration, The Tenth Youth, Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1940.


Above: Many African American artists were hired into the WPA. Here we see Louisiana Small, working in the WPA's Federal Art Project in Washington, DC, ca. 1938. Between 1935 and 1943, the number of different African Americans receiving jobs in the WPA--on all types of projects--was probably around 1.2 million (see discussion at the end of this blog post). Photo from the National Archives.


Above: African American WPA workers transcribing legislative records in Baltimore City, ca. 1936. The WPA also located, inventoried, and preserved vital statistics records, all across the nation, which genealogists still use today. Photo from the University of Maryland College Park Archives.


Above: A man operates a roller at Bolling Field airport (now part of "Joint Base Anacostia-Bolling"), Washington, DC, November 1936. 1,000 WPA men, working with the U.S. Army Quartermaster Corps, carried out large-scale upgrades to the airfield ("W.P.A. Completing New Bolling Field," The Sunday Star (Washington, DC), August 16, 1936, p. B-4). Photo from the National Archives.

Above: These men are working on the new Chicago subway system, June 1940. The project was funded by the New Deal's Public Works Administration (PWA). The PWA's director, Harold Ickes, was adamant that African Americans receive a fair share of jobs created by PWA stimulus money: "[He] stipulated that all PWA contracts include a clause specifying that the number of blacks hired and their percentage of the project payroll be equal to the proportion of blacks in the 1930 occupational census. Although sometimes disregarded by local officials and contractors, it nevertheless resulted in unprecedented wages for many black laborers..." (Harvard Sitkoff, A New Deal for Blacks: The Emergence of Civil Rights as a National Issue: The Depression Decade, 30th Anniversary Edition, 2009, p. 50.). Photo from the National Archives.

Above: This table comes from the annual report of the Federal Works Agency, fiscal year 1942, p. 125. The total number of these jobs that were new jobs for African Americans--as a result of Harold Ickes' mandate for racial fairness--is probably impossible to know. For example, a private firm working on a PWA-funded construction job may already have had African Americans on its payroll. Still, the table is interesting because it indicates that a large number of jobs for African Americans were either created or maintained through PWA loans and grants: "The Public Works Administration (PWA) established quotas to ensure that black workers, and particularly skilled black workers, were hired in construction projects the agency funded. In 1936 [for example], blacks accounted for more than 30 percent of the PWA payroll and made up more than 15 percent of skilled workers in the program - a proportion greater than overall black representation among skilled workers. And black workers accounted for more than 20 percent of the PWA's semiskilled workers and nearly two-thirds of its unskilled employees" (Adolph Reed, Jr., "The New Deal Wasn’t Intrinsically Racist: How today’s focus on 'racial disparity' can distort our understanding of structural inequality," The New Republic, November 26, 2019).


Above: Sometimes people are against racial quotas, and sometimes for good reason; but there are times when racial discrimination is so explicit and systemic that action is needed. This newspaper excerpt, from the Journal and Guide (Norfolk, Virginia), September 10, 1938, highlights why the racial quotas established by Harold Ickes and the PWA were in many cases needed. Image from newspapers.com, used here for educational and non-commercial purposes.


Above: The Mary McLeod Bethune Memorial in Washington, DC. "Mary McLeod Bethune was the director of the National Youth Administration’s (NYA) Office of Negro Affairs, c. 1936-1943, and a founding member of the 'Black Cabinet,' a group that advised President Roosevelt on issues important to African Americans" ("Mary McLeod Bethune," Living New Deal, accessed December 15, 2025). "Past presidents had given only a handful of honorific posts to blacks; Roosevelt appointed over one hundred African Americans to administrative positions, most of them directly relating to the pressing problems of blacks" (Harvard Sitkoff, A New Deal for Blacks: The Emergence of Civil Rights as a National Issue: The Depression Decade, 30th Anniversary Edition, 2009, pp. 57-58). Photo by Brent McKee, 2018.

Jobs for African Americans

Trying to determine the total number of African Americans who received employment via the New Deal is difficult, because demographic record-keeping during those times was not a sophisticated or as thorough as modern record-keeping. With that in mind, let's see what we can do...

CCC:

We know that the CCC enrolled about 250,000 African Americans (see second photo and caption of this blog post), and we know this is a conservative estimate because the number is based on a May 1940 report, two years before the CCC ended. Of course, some men enrolled in the CCC more than once, but since the 250,000 figure does not include the final two years of the CCC it is probably a good (albeit rough) estimate of the total number of different African Americans who served in the Corps.

NYA:

The NYA employed about 300,000 different African Americans by the end of fiscal year 1940, for its in-school and out-of-school programs combined, out of a total of 2,580,000 total hires by that time (statistics here and here) - about 11.6%. 

Applying that 11.6% figure to the NYA's total employment of 4,811,000 (fiscal years 1936-1943, statistics here and here), we get a rough estimate of 558,000 different African Americans hired into the NYA. This is likely also a conservative estimate, because Whites had more success in securing private sector jobs during the early war years, which often increased the percentage of Blacks in the work-relief programs. In other words, the 11.6% figure probably increased during the last years of the NYA.

WPA:

The WPA probably employed more African Americans than any other single employer--either government or private sector--in the New Deal era. During the largest employment years of the WPA, 1935-1940, the percentage of African American workers was typically around 14% (the percentage increased significantly in the final years of the WPA). Altogether, 8.5 million different Americans worked in the WPA, so 14% would give us about 1,190,000 different African Americans employed by the WPA (admittedly a rough estimation, but read on).

(Note: In regard to the 14% figure, see, Federal Works Agency, Final Report on the WPA Program, 1935-43, Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1947, p. 45; Donald S. Howard, The WPA and Federal Relief Policy, New York: Russell Sage Foundation, 1943, pp. 288-289; and Samuel Hammond, "No, the New Deal Wasn't Racist," American Compass, October 12, 2020.)  

There are indications that African Americans may have stayed in the WPA for longer periods of time--again, because Whites often had an easier time securing private sector jobs--which might lower the estimate, but since the percentage of African Americans in the WPA increased in the later years--ranging from 16-20%--perhaps that evens things out. Again, rough estimates are necessary since demographic record-keeping was not as thorough as it could have been.

Lastly, with respect to the 1,190,000 estimate--and its likely conservative nature--it was reported that about 500,000 different African Americans were employed in the WPA, at one time or another, in 1940 alone ("Lauds Co-Operation in Fight On Unemployment," The Chicago Defender, March 8, 1941, p. 8). 

Civil Service:

The New Deal also increased the number of African Americans in regular federal jobs (i.e., not temporary work-relief jobs): "In 1941 the civil service listed over one hundred and fifty thousand black federal employees. Less than fifty thousand had worked for the government when Hoover left office [in 1933]" (Harvard Sitkoff, A New Deal for Blacks: The Emergence of Civil Rights as a National Issue: The Depression Decade, 30th Anniversary Edition, 2009, p. 57).

Summary:

If we add up the CCC (250,000), NYA (558,000), WPA (1,190,000), and the increase in regular federal employment (100,000), we get 2,098,000 African Americans receiving employment from the New Deal. Keep in mind that this figure does not include the large programs of CWA and FERA (which, combined, created over 6 million jobs from 1933-1935); smaller programs, such as the Virgin Islands Company (a PWA-funded program that hired many African Americans); and African Americans that received employment as a direct result of PWA's racial fairness directives. These numbers are largely unknown (or at least, unclear) but would likely increase our estimate to 2.5 or perhaps even 3 million.

In examining the New Deal employment statistics for African Americans, the main complexity is: How many different African Americans received New Deal employment? For example, one can imagine a person receiving an NYA job in 1936, and then a WPA job in 1941. That's two New Deal jobs, but only one African American person. 

At a minimum though, given all the information, statistics, and conservative calculations discussed above, I think we can confidently say that the New Deal hired over two million different African Americans between 1933 and 1943.

Tuesday, December 9, 2025

New Deal Accomplishment: 10 million Americans received affordable electricity through TVA in 2025


Above: Construction work at the Douglas Dam, part of the Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA), Sevier County, Tennessee, 1942. TVA was created in 1933 by FDR and the New Deal Congress, in order to control flooding, mitigate soil erosion, and produce affordable electricity; and also to improve the economic situation for the poverty-stricken Tennessee Valley area. Photo by Alfred T. Palmer, Farm Security Administration, courtesy of the Library of Congress.


Above: A TVA locomotive, to assist in construction and operations. Unknown photographer, scanned from a personal collection.


Above: The hydro-electric Douglas Dam, on the French Broad River, still providing affordable electricity 83 years later. It is one of 29 hydro-electric dams operated by TVA, 17 of which were built between 1933 and 1945 (see: Robert D. Leighninger Jr., Long-Range Public Investment: The Forgotten Legacy of the New Deal, The University of South Carolina Press, 2007, p. 112). Photo from TVA.


Above: A 2023 map showing "TVA's Service Area and Power Generation Assets." Image from TVA and Wikimedia Commons.


Above: A WPA poster, promoting the WPA production of Power, a play about public vs. private ownership of electric utilities. TVA and other New Deal electric initiatives (like the Rural Electrification Administration, REA) were considered triumphs over investor-owned utilities that were hesitant, unwilling, or simply unable to provide affordable power to rural areas. In Power, a man complains that he doesn't have the money to pay for the poles and wires needed to bring electricity to his farm. The manager of a private utility replies, "I'm sorry, Mr. Parker, but that's the way we operate. I'm afraid I can't do a thing for you." Image courtesy of the Library of Congress.


Above: This booklet, ca. 1954, explains how TVA ended up helping the private sector, despite the hyperbolic fears of "communism" and "socialism" that public ownership of utilities--or, for that matter, public ownership of just about anything--always conjures up. The booklet highlights increased manufacturing (higher than the national average); higher consumer spending; better transportation of goods along the Tennessee River (thanks to the TVA's dams, locks, and river-deepening); recreation (think tourism business); orders for materials to create TVA infrastructure; improved agriculture; and, ironically, increased business for private utilities. Image scanned from a private copy.


Above: Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC) Company 491, working out of Camp TVA-19, building a pavilion near Norris Lake, Tennessee - one of the many pavilions they built across the nation, many still in use today. Nearly 200 CCC camps were located in the TVA area. Company 491's projects included soil erosion control, reforestation, fire control (e.g., construction of firebreaks, lookout towers, truck trails, and telephone lines), firefighting, and the development of picnic areas. Photo from: Civilian Conservation Corps, Official Annual, District C, Fourth Corps Area (Direct Advertising Company, 1937), used here for educational and non-commercial purposes.


Above: Endless millions of Americans created (and still create today) endless millions of memories in campgrounds, parks, and other recreational areas around TVA. This photo comes from the TVA brochure, "Recreation on TVA lakes," ca. 1966 edition. Image scanned from a personal copy.


Above: "Recreation on TVA Lakes," ca. 1972 edition. Today, TVA offers areas for fishing, boating, whitewater rafting, live music, hunting, hiking, camping, and more. Image scanned from a personal copy.


Above: An old postcard of Norris Dam, part of the TVA system, published by the Asheville Post Card Co., Asheville, North Carolina. Image used here for educational and non-commercial purposes.

The Colossal and Enduring Legacy of the New Deal's TVA

In the play Power (see WPA poster above), Jean Thomas's TVA Song is included, and the lyrics read in part: "All up and down the valley, they heard the glad alarm; the Government means business, it's working like a charm."

Later, Pete Seeger wrote a song about TVA that included: "Where once private power said it couldn’t be done, you can see farm lights twinkling, you can hear high lines hum; Fertilizer and science are reclaiming the soil, and REA co-ops help lighten the toil."

Today, TVA is still working like a charm (albeit with room for improvement), supplying affordable electricity--lower rates than investor-owned utilities--to 10 million people across Tennessee, Alabama, Mississippi, Kentucky, North Carolina, Georgia, and Virginia.

There are, of course, persistent pressures to privatize TVA, since a for-profit model--centered on rate increases--would make owners and shareholders wealthy. See, for example: "Privatizing the Tennessee Valley Authority Would Increase Costs and Hurt Reliability," Economic Policy Institute, June 4, 2015; and "At public hearing, Knoxville residents push back on privatization of Tennessee Valley Authority: Comments come after threats to nation’s largest public utility by President Donald Trump," Tennessee Lookout, August 26, 2025.

TVA was built on the principles of public ownership of power (the common good), affordable electricity, and democracy. Let's keep it that way.

Saturday, December 6, 2025

New Deal Accomplishment: 6.7 million dams - from small and temporary (95+ percent), to mid-size and multi-use, to large and power-producing


Above: The description for this photograph--taken in May 1940--reads: "Erosion gully, with CCC (Civilian Conservation Corps) building a check dam. Monona County, Iowa." From 1933-1942, the CCC built 6,659,223 check dams - 6,341,147 were temporary and 318,076 were permanent. Check dams slow down water run-off after heavy rains, thereby reducing soil erosion and downstream pollution, and also allow water more time to sink into the ground. They are often built in non-fish-bearing gullies, ditches, wet weather streams, and other areas that are dry most of the year. Check dams allow for re-vegetation of eroded areas. Photo above by John Vachon, Farm Security Administration, and provided courtesy of the Library of Congress.


Above: Members of CCC Company 3747--stationed at Camp SCS [Soil Conservation Service]-Mo-12, Paris, Missouri--installing check dams. These were probably temporary check dams, designed to slow down the velocity of water run-off until vegetation--planted by the CCC--could take hold. Photo from: Civilian Conservation Corps, Official Annual, 1937, Missouri-Kansas District, Seventh Corps Area (Baton Rouge, Louisiana: Direct Advertising Co., 1937). Used here for educational and non-commercial purposes.


Above: A more permanent type of check dam, being constructed by enrollees of CCC Company 1742, working out of Camp SCS-Mo-3, Tarkio, Missouri. "When rainfall does not quickly leave watersheds as surface runoff, it has the opportunity to infiltrate, providing soil moisture that supports vegetation and wildlife" ("Restoring Water Flows on Private Land," U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, accessed December 5, 2025). For photo credit, see previous caption.


Above: The CCC also built larger dams, such as this one being constructed by CCC Company 4755, stationed at Camp SCS-27, Marion, Kansas. This dam created Marion County Lake, designed to relieve drought and provide recreation. Today, it is on the National Register of Historic Places. For photo credit, see two captions above.


Above: WPA workers building the Johnsons Pond Dam, Salisbury, Maryland, 1936. This dam was part of a broader project to repair, replace, and improve infrastructure (including an older dam) that had failed during a flood in 1933. The aftermath of the flood had turned a pond "noted for its scenic beauty" into a stagnant "harbor for mosquito breeding" ("Isabella Dam, Pond Project Put Up To WPA," The Salisbury Times, August 17, 1935, p. 1). Photo from the University of Maryland College Park Archives.


Above: Small dams built by the WPA, in Silver Spring Township, Pennsylvania, to facilitate trout fishing, 1937. The WPA built tens of thousands of dams for a variety of purposes, for example, erosion control check dams, flood control dams, and dams to provide recreation, irrigation, and drinking water for nearby areas. In conjunction with the U.S. Bureau of Biological Survey (merged with the Bureau of Fisheries in 1939 to create the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service) the WPA constructed "dams, dikes, and ditches to improve water areas and create marshes, thus promoting the growth of cover and food required by migratory water fowl and shore birds" (Report on Progress of the WPA Program, June 30, 1939, p. 123). Photo from the National Archives.


Above: Most of the dams built by the WPA were on the smaller side, but some were fairly large, such as Rockview Dam in Pennsylvania, built to supply water for a nearby prison. This dam also highlights the risk of over-counting some New Deal projects. The dam was started by the New Deal's Civil Works Administration (CWA), likely continued under the Work Division of the Federal Emergency Relief Administration (FERA), and then completed by the WPA. Though worked on by three agencies it is obviously just one New Deal project. Photo from the National Archives.

Above: The New Deal's Public Works Administration (PWA) funded many hydro-electric dams, such as the Mansfield Dam, near Austin, Texas. This photo shows the dam under construction between 1937 and 1942. The Mansfield Dam was "intended primarily for flood control but also will generate electric power and provide water for irrigation" ("Marshall Ford Dam Dedicated By Secretary Harold Ickes," The Amarillo Globe (Amarillo, Texas), February 19, 1937, p. 2). Photo from the National Archives.


Above: A map showing the locations of hydro-electric dams receiving PWA funds. From the PWA publication, America Builds: The Record of PWA (Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1939).


Above: The PWA-financed Bonneville Dam, between Oregon and Washington, nearing completion, ca. 1938. The electricity produced by the dam provided power for defense industries in the region during World War II. After the war, President Harry Truman said: "Without Grand Coulee [another New Deal project] and Bonneville dams it would have been almost impossible to win this war." Today, the Bonneville Dam is a National Historic Landmark with "18 turbine units and a total generating capacity of over 1,200 megawatts - enough to power 900,000 homes" ("Bonneville Dam and Lake Bonneville," U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, accessed December 5, 2025). Photo from the National Archives.


Above: Dams disrupt ecosystems, and it has been an ongoing challenge to minimize their impact. The description for this photograph, taken ca. 1938, reads: "The man sitting on the platform at the left counts salmon as they use a Bonneville Dam fish ladder to work upstream. These ladders at the Dam were constructed by PWA." Photo from the National Archives.


Above: From a 2013 Army Corps of Engineers visitor brochure, for Bonneville Dam. Scanned from a personal copy.


Above: Another image from the 2013 brochure, showing systems--in addition to the fish ladders--that are designed to allow fish to pass by the Bonneville Dam. Scanned from a personal copy.


Above: The PWA-funded Tygart Dam in Grafton, West Virginia, built primarily to control flooding. The dam created the 10-mile long Tygart Lake which provides numerous recreation opportunities, such as hiking, playgrounds, swimming, water-skiing, fishing, and even scuba diving. The dam was designed to be retrofitted with electric-producing turbines, and recently a firm has committed to do just that ("Agilitas Energy Acquires Hydropower Projects in West Virginia and Maryland," The Well News, June 26, 2025). Photo by Brent McKee, 2012.


Above: The entrance to the PWA-funded Tygart Dam, Grafton, West Virginia. According to a 2013 article by the Army Corps of Engineers, "The Tygart Dam was part of the second wave of President Roosevelt’s New Deal, which was designed to help revitalize struggling communities during the Great Depression... At the peak of construction in May 1936, 1,701 men worked on the structure. Jobs at the dam were in high demand, with men being paid 45 cents an hour for unskilled labor and $1.10 an hour for skilled labor... The main purposes the dam serves are flood control, navigation... public water supply, recreation, land conservation and fish and wildlife preservation... Since its completion, the dam has prevented flood damages in excess of $1.4 billion." The Tygart Dam is on the National Register of Historic Places. Photo by Brent McKee, 2012.


Above: The Dos Bocas Dam, Puerto Rico, 2017. This dam was constructed by the New Deal's Puerto Rico Reconstruction Administration (PRRA), between 1937 and 1942, and was part of a larger initiative to bring more electricity to more Puerto Ricans (for a full discussion on these projects, see pp. 114-137 in Geoff Burrow's book, The Puerto Rico Reconstruction Administration: New Deal Public Works, Modernization, and Colonial Reform, University of Florida Press, 2024). The Dos Bocas Dam is currently producing electricity at well below intended capacity, but there are efforts to restore the facility to full electric production (see, e.g., "Hydro Energy Reborn," Cooperativa Hidroeléctrica de la Montaña, accessed December 5, 2025). Photo by an employee of the U.S. Government, provided courtesy of Wikimedia Commons.


Above: "Spillway, Ashokan Dam," an oil painting by Arnold Wiltz (1889-1937), created while he was in the New Deal's Public Works of Art Project, 1934. The Ashokan Reservoir is located in Ulster County, New York, and helps supply water to New York City. Image from the Smithsonian American Art Museum.

Dammed if you do, dammed if you don't

Just using statistics from the CCC, WPA, and National Youth Administration (NYA) (see "Statistical Note" below) we arrive at 6.7 million new dams constructed, and over 181,000 other projects to maintain or improve existing dams.

The vast majority of these new dams--temporary check dams--were very beneficial and had few downsides, especially those installed in non-fish-bearing (and normally dry) gullies and ditches. In most instances, these were installed to correct problems created by deforestation, less-than-ideal farming methods, and extreme weather events. They aided soil conservation, plant growth, and wildlife preservation.

Other dams have more mixed records, since the costs--disruptions of ecosystems--can be very significant. There is currently a movement to remove dams that have outlasted their usefulness and let nature return to its pre-dam state in those areas (see, e.g., "Why America Is Removing Thousands of Dams and Letting Rivers Run Free: Excerpt," Resilience, December 5, 2025).

Hydro-electric dams present the dilemma of (a) large amounts of efficient, clean, and relatively inexpensive electricity, vs. (b) their disruption to rivers. To see how contentious debates can be about their existence and removal, see the comments section for the article, "Four Things To Know About the Impacts of Dam Removal on the Klamath River" (American Rivers, May 17, 2024).

Every source of energy has its downsides and detractors, for example: fossil fuels are heating the planet and killing millions (likely making it the worst energy source); nuclear power has caused catastrophes; wind turbines kill birds and bats; solar farms are creating land conflicts; geothermal projects can cause earthquakes; and our increasing use of batteries is raising waste management issues.

Perhaps the best we can do is just keep trying, trying, and trying to make energy--from various sources--more efficient, clean, safe, and equitable. As FDR said, "It is common sense to take a method and try it: If it fails, admit it frankly and try another. But above all, try something."

(Statistical note: Due to a variety of factors--such as (a) single work projects that spanned over the course of multiple work-relief agencies, (b) more than one agency working on the same project at the same time, and (c) inadequate reporting--calculating the total New Deal work product for any category of projects can range from mildly challenging to extraordinarily difficult. I therefore use several methods--for example, leaving out the work product of one or more agencies--to keep the estimates modest, as opposed to overblown. My earliest blog posts go into these difficulties and methods in more detail.)